A fixed-fee alternative to a recruitment agency

Yes, there are alternatives to a contingency agency that charge a fixed fee for the search rather than a percentage of salary. A flat-fee recruiter runs the whole process for one published price. A research service finds and ranks the candidates for one price, and your own team does the outreach and interviews. On a senior role, either costs a fraction of a 20% to 35% agency fee.

Cruvo is a research service. You send the brief, and in days, not weeks, we return a market map and a ranked long-list of external candidates with the reasoning for each name. We charge a flat fee per search, never a percentage of salary. A person reviews every list before it reaches you, and your team runs outreach and interviews.

Updated

What each option costs on a £140,000 VP of Engineering hire

The example from a common brief: a UK scale-up hiring a VP of Engineering on £140,000, with an agency quote of 25%. Percentages are applied to the salary alone; fee terms often include bonus and benefits too.

Contingency agency

How you pay
A percentage of first-year salary, only if you hire
On a £140,000 hire
£21,000 at 15%, £35,000 at 25%, £49,000 at a 35% list rate
Who does the work
The agency finds, approaches and screens candidates
Fits when
You want the whole process done and pay only on success

Retained executive search

How you pay
25% to 35% of first-year pay, in thirds: at the start, at shortlist, at offer or start
On a £140,000 hire
£35,000 to £49,000
Who does the work
The search firm runs the whole search
Fits when
Board-level, confidential or very scarce roles

Embedded recruiter

How you pay
A monthly fee, often plus a fee per hire
On a £140,000 hire
For example £5,500 a month plus 8% of salary per hire at one UK provider
Who does the work
A recruiter works inside your team
Fits when
Several hires in a short burst

Flat-fee recruiter

How you pay
One published price, usually banded by salary
On a £140,000 hire
Around £6,000 plus VAT for £80,000+ roles at one UK provider; others quote above £60,000
Who does the work
They advertise, screen and send a shortlist
Fits when
Roles that advertising can fill

Research service (Cruvo)

How you pay
A flat fee per search, agreed on a short call
On a £140,000 hire
The same fee whatever the salary
Who does the work
We map the market and rank the candidates; your team approaches them
Fits when
Senior or hard roles where the right people are not applying

Agency and retained rates are from Robert Walters' and Reed's published UK terms and Hiring Hub's fee guide; embedded and flat-fee prices are Hurren & Hope's and Talent Finder UK's published list prices. The sums are ours. See Sources.

How to fill one senior role without an agency

  1. 1

    Write the brief with the hiring manager

    Agree the must-haves, the backgrounds that would work and what rules someone out. A sharp brief is what makes a fixed fee go far.

  2. 2

    Get the market researched

    Ask for a map of the companies the person could come from and a ranked long-list with the evidence for each name. See how adjacent sectors widen the pool.

  3. 3

    Approach the strongest people yourself

    Use the reasons on the list to write each approach. A message that says why you thought of someone gets more replies than a template.

  4. 4

    Interview and decide

    Your team runs interviews and the offer, as it would with any shortlist.

  5. 5

    Keep the research

    The map and the candidate records stay with you, so the next hire in the same market starts from them.

What you take on when you drop the agency

A fixed fee is cheaper because some of the work moves to your team. Be sure you can cover it.

Outreach

Someone has to approach candidates, follow up and keep track of replies. For a senior role, that is a few hours a week for several weeks.

Candidate experience

Passive candidates expect a prompt, personal process. Plan who answers their questions and how quickly.

Selling the role

An agency often pitches the company. Without one, the hiring manager needs to be ready to make the case in the first conversation.

Referencing and offer

References, salary negotiation and the offer stay with you, as they do with most in-house hires.

Common questions

How much do recruitment agencies charge in the UK?

Contingency agencies typically charge 15% to 25% of first-year salary, and some large agencies' standard terms list 25% to 35% depending on the salary band. Retained executive search usually costs 25% to 35% of first-year pay, paid in three stages.

Is there an agency alternative that charges a fixed fee per search?

Yes. Flat-fee recruiters charge one published price per role, and research services such as Cruvo charge a flat fee per search for a ranked long-list your team then approaches. Neither is tied to the salary.

Does Cruvo contact the candidates?

No. Cruvo finds and assesses candidates and explains why each one fits. Your team runs outreach, interviews and the offer.

What if the first list isn't right?

We refine it with your feedback. Briefs change once the hiring manager sees real candidates, and the research changes with them.

When is an agency still the better choice?

When nobody on your side has time to approach candidates and run the process, or when you only want to pay if someone is hired.

Bring the difficult brief.

Talk us through the role, or email the job description and the notes you already have to hello@cruvo.app. You get a ranked long-list with the reasoning behind every name, in days, not weeks.

Book a Call