Home / Learn

Retained and contingent search compared

Retained search pays for an agreed assignment, often with one firm appointed exclusively. A contingent agency usually earns its fee when a placement satisfies the engagement terms. Compare the work proposed for your appointment as well as the payment model, including research, contact, assessment and your team’s remaining responsibilities.

In short

  • Read the payment triggers and commitments in the proposal before comparing the two search models.
  • Ask how the firm will investigate the candidate market and establish the experience you need.
  • Buy research separately when the employer or search consultant already owns contact, assessment and hiring.

The retained or contingent label tells you something about payment, but you also need a description of the work. Retained firms are paid for an assignment, commonly on an exclusive basis. Contingent agencies usually earn a fee when their placement meets agreed conditions. Under either model, establish how the consultant will search for people, contact them and assess the experience the appointment requires.

For a confidential leadership role, the employer may need careful control of approaches and sustained advice throughout selection. For a familiar recurring vacancy, an agency’s existing reach may be useful. Ask each firm to work from the same brief and explain its route to candidates. You can then judge the scope against the hire and compare the payments, responsibilities and commitments in the proposals.

Payment and commitment

Retained proposals commonly set out staged fees and an exclusive assignment. Contingent proposals usually make payment conditional on a placement. The agreement should specify the event that triggers each fee and the work covered by it.

Discuss changes before the search begins. A revised role, paused assignment or candidate found internally may affect the engagement. Ask the supplier to explain those cases in its own terms. This avoids relying on a general description when the actual agreement differs, and makes it easier to compare the money and responsibilities your company would commit to each proposal.

The search scope

Request an account of the research and assessment the firm will perform. Which companies will it investigate? How will it handle approaches, and what will you learn about each person presented? Agree when the hiring manager will review progress and how changes to the brief will be handled.

The AESC guide describes executive search work spanning identification, assessment and selection support. C2 Recruitment discusses the role and depth of search when comparing models. Use those distinctions in the supplier conversation, then record the work actually proposed for your appointment.

Choosing for the appointment

Consider a retained assignment when the work requires sustained market research and consultant involvement. Contingency can fit a familiar vacancy where an agency has relevant reach and a suitable placement process. In both cases, look at the firm’s experience and the hiring work your team can perform.

For example, a confidential replacement may require controlled approaches to candidates across a carefully defined market. A recurring operational hire may draw on people an agency already knows. These examples help frame the conversation, but the proposed scope must fit the actual role. The employer still needs to assess candidates and make decisions.

Research within either model

An employer or search firm can commission research while continuing to run the search. The additional work is finding people, investigating their backgrounds and explaining why they may fit. The hiring owner uses those findings to decide which conversations to begin.

Cruvo supplies that research as a ranked long-list with supporting evidence. It charges a flat fee per brief and no success fee. The client handles candidate contact and hiring. When comparing this with a full search engagement, list the tasks your team can already perform and the tasks it needs a supplier to take on.

FAQ

What is the main difference between the models?

Retained fees pay for a defined search assignment, commonly through staged payments. A contingent fee usually becomes due when a placement meets the agreed conditions. The proposal sets the exact arrangement.

Does retained search always require an exclusive agreement?

Exclusivity is common, but read its boundaries in the agreement. Discuss the period covered and what happens when a candidate comes through your own team.

Does contingent recruitment always have no upfront costs?

Ask the agency to state all charges and when they apply. Placement fees may sit alongside separately agreed services such as advertising or assessment; the proposal should make that clear.

Is retained search only suitable for executive roles?

No. A difficult specialist role can also need sustained research and consultant attention. Judge whether that work justifies the proposed scope and commitment for the appointment.

Which model will fill the role more quickly?

Neither label establishes speed. Ask how the consultant would sequence the work and what it depends on, including candidate availability and the time your interviewers can provide.

Should we use several contingent agencies at once?

Consider the reach each agency adds and the risk of overlapping approaches. Agree who tracks introductions and candidate communication before several suppliers start working in the same market.

Can a retained firm buy Cruvo candidate research?

Yes. Cruvo supplies research to search firms. The consultant keeps responsibility for candidate discussions, assessment and the relationship with the employer commissioning the search.

Is Cruvo’s fee a full executive-search retainer?

No. The fee covers research against the brief. The employer or search firm remains responsible for candidate contact, interviews and the final hiring decision.

Payment terms describe the commercial arrangement; the agreed scope describes the hiring work delivered.

Sources

Talk with Cruvo

If your team already runs the search and needs more research capacity, we can discuss the appointment with you. We work with employers and search firms, and can explain the research Cruvo would provide.

Or email hello@cruvo.app directly.