Measuring a sourcing search through hiring outcomes
A useful search record follows people from review through contact, interviews and hires. Keep the costs with that search and define each stage before comparing results. This helps your team explain what happened, give Cruvo specific feedback and decide which part of the next search needs to change.
In short
- Agree what success means for the role and record when you will review the results.
- Track each stage separately, including how many people were contacted and how many progressed to interviews.
- Calculate cost per hire using the same cost categories, then use the findings to improve the next search.
The first result of a search is the list. The hiring results follow as your team reviews candidates and speaks with them. Record that sequence to see which people progressed and where decisions changed. A single total, whether names delivered or hires made, leaves much of that work unexplained.
Use the system your team already works in, such as an ATS or spreadsheet. Attach the brief and a search identifier to the record. The stages below follow the research into your team’s hiring activity, giving you a common basis for discussing the engagement and deciding what the next search should do differently.
What should you agree before research starts?
Agree the result the search should support, who will record progress and when you will review it. For a live vacancy, follow relevant conversations through interviews to an appointment. Define the event that counts as reaching each stage before the numbers accumulate.
An introductory recruiter call may count as an interview in one team and as screening in another. Choose your definition and keep it visible. Record the delivery and outreach dates too. A recent approach needs time to receive a reply, so compare results over periods that give candidates a similar opportunity to respond.
How do you measure the candidate funnel?
Count people at each stage and keep the denominator visible. A practical sequence is reviewed, selected for contact, contacted, replied, interested, interviewed, offered and hired. Record each candidate once within a stage, even when several messages or interviews occur.
For reply rate, divide people who replied by people contacted. For interview conversion from contact, divide people interviewed by people contacted. State those definitions beside the figures. In an illustrative search, 40 contacts and eight replies produce a 20% reply rate. Four interviews from those contacts produce 10% interview conversion. Use this calculation with your own search figures. Workable’s metrics guide discusses stage conversions.
What does each stalled stage tell you?
Start with the point where candidates stop progressing. Rejection before contact calls for a look at relevance: the brief, the evidence and the assessment. Profile-specific reasons help Cruvo understand whether the research missed something or the requirement needs clarification.
Low response after relevant approaches raises questions about the message, timing and opportunity. Declines after a reply need the candidate’s explanation. Interview rejection may reveal a requirement that the early brief did not capture well enough. Use the numbers to locate the problem and the feedback to investigate it before deciding what to change.
How should you calculate cost per hire?
Divide the costs assigned to the search by the hires it produced. Decide which costs to include first. A full hiring calculation can include research fees, advertising, recruitment tools and internal time. A narrower research-cost measure should be labelled clearly so it is not mistaken for the full cost.
Cruvo charges a flat fee per brief, without a success fee. Record the agreed fee in your private calculation alongside the other costs you include. If the search has produced no hire, record the cost and current outcomes; you can calculate cost per hire once someone is hired. Use the same cost categories when comparing searches.
How do findings improve the next search?
Review the outcomes alongside the brief and the reasons candidates gave you. Useful feedback goes beyond the total: which backgrounds progressed, which requirements excluded strong people and which terms prevented an otherwise relevant conversation from continuing.
Separate people already known to your team from newly researched contacts when that distinction matters to your evaluation. Preserve the source and search identifier in your records. Workable’s source-tracking guidance shows why source definitions need care. For the next Cruvo brief, combine what the research revealed with what your team learned through contact. That gives the next search a better starting point.
FAQ
Is the number of names a useful success measure?
It tells you how many people the research returned. Follow that count with how many met the brief, received contact and progressed. The sequence shows how your team used the list and which decisions need closer examination.
Should every candidate be contacted before we measure?
No. Measure replies against people who received an approach. Record reviewed and selected candidates separately, so you can see your team’s decisions before contact. Including people who were never approached would obscure the response rate.
What counts as a reply in the report?
Define it before reporting. Count human replies and record interest separately, so a decline can be seen without being counted as interest. Decide how automated responses and delivery failures will be recorded, then apply that rule consistently.
What is a good interview conversion rate?
Use your own role context and a consistent definition before setting a target. Seniority, market size, offer terms and outreach timing affect the result. The useful first comparison is between similar searches measured over comparable periods.
How do we measure a search with no hire?
Record the cost and the stages reached so far. Relevant interviews can show progress even while the role remains open. Examine why candidates stopped progressing, and avoid reporting cost per hire until a hire supplies the denominator.
Can one search contribute to more than one hire?
Yes, if your team hires more than one person from the research. Record the actual hires and the costs included. If a person is hired for a later role, preserve the original source and explain how you attribute the outcome.
Does Cruvo provide a complete outcome analytics dashboard?
Use your ATS or a shared record for the full hiring funnel. Cruvo records candidate activity and outreach; your team has later interview, offer and hire outcomes. Review them together to follow the research through the hiring process.
Who should review the results with the research team?
Include the people who reviewed candidates and handled their conversations. They can explain why someone progressed or stopped. The hiring manager can add what interviews revealed, including requirements that became clearer during selection.
Sources
Talk with Cruvo
Tell us where you are with the hire. We can discuss the role, show you how the research works and talk through how your team would use it. You can start with questions or an unfinished brief.
Or email hello@cruvo.app directly.